Research Article |
Corresponding author: Petr Bogusch ( bogusch.petr@gmail.com ) Academic editor: Jack Neff
© 2023 Petr Bogusch.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Bogusch P (2023) European cuckoo bees of the tribe Dioxyini (Hymenoptera, Megachilidae): distribution, annotated checklist and identification key. Journal of Hymenoptera Research 96: 599-628. https://doi.org/10.3897/jhr.96.104957
|
Altogether, ten species of cuckoo bees of the tribe Dioxyini have been recorded from Europe, with two species distributed widely in the continent while others are restricted in distribution to only one or several countries in southern Europe. These ten representatives are classified into five genera: Aglaoapis, Dioxys, Ensliniana, Metadioxys and Paradioxys. Dioxys atlanticus is reclassified from a subspecies to a valid species, and new occurrence records of this species are reported. New synonymy is established for Dioxys cinctus = D. montana syn. nov. The distribution, morphology, ecology and hosts of all species were reviewed from both published and unpublished sources. New red-list categories for each species were created according to the new records of occurrence. An identification key including all ten species and photographs of their whole bodies and main identification characteristics was prepared, and distribution maps for all species were created.
Europe, Aglaoapis, Dioxys, Ensliniana, Metadioxys, Paradioxys, maps, ecology, hosts, conservation
Bees (Anthophila) form a group of seven families within the monophylum Aculeata inside the highly diversified order Hymenoptera. This group coevolved with flowering plants, whose pollen, nectar and oils serve as the main food sources for both adults and their brood (
Interspecific cuckoo behaviour is known in four families: Colletidae, Halictidae, Megachilidae and Apidae, including the species-rich subfamily Nomadinae of the family Apidae which is comprised of many genera and species (
The goal of this study is to review the taxonomy, distribution, ecology and conservation of all species of tribe Dioxyini recorded from Europe. An identification key for all species is included.
The specimens for the study were collected by the author from the field or obtained from other collections. A large part of the material studied included pinned specimens from both private and museum collections. Additionally, material from the following museums and institutions was studied: Národní muzeum, Praha (Czech Republic, curator Jan Macek), Moravské zemské muzeum, Brno (Czech Republic, curator Igor Malenovský), Natural History Museum, London (United Kingdom, curator Joseph Monks), Naturhistorisches Museum, Wien (Austria, curator Manuela Vizek), Biologiezentrum Linz (Austria, curator Esther Öckermüller), Naturhistorisches Museum Berlin (Germany, curator Stefanie Krause), and Naturkundemuseum Bayern Munich (Germany, curator Stefan Schmidt). Several records were obtained from internet sources, especially from photos on Flickr (https://www.flickr.com/) and iNaturalist (https://www.inaturalist.com/). In this case, only records from specialists or photos enabling identification to the species level were included. However, the goal of this study was not to create detailed maps of distribution, because this work will be done in several European bee projects in the near future and occurrence records from local authorities, taxonomic specialists and museums are still not completely collected and validated.
The author examined only a part of the type material of both valid species and synonyms and all the original descriptions of all species and their synonyms. The type material was not studied in most cases because the description of the species is comprehensive and clear, and/or there was rich material available in private or museum collections for study, so the examination of the original types was not necessary. All of the type material studied by the author is indicated in the taxonomic treatment sections of species.
Morphology was studied using a digital Keyence VHX-700 photographing microscope with measuring tools. Only specimens clearly exhibiting diagnostic features were imaged. The identification keys for females and males are dichotomous, using the following standard abbreviations before the corresponding number: S – metasomal sternum, T – metasomal tergum, and F – flagellomere. Figure abbreviations in brackets (Fig.
Species distributions were determined using studied material and literary sources on Dioxyini of Europe. Distribution maps were created in QGIS 3.6. The red-list categories from
1 | Scutellum without lateral projections (Fig. |
Ensliniana bidentata (Spain and Portugal) |
– | Scutellum with lateral toothlike projections (Fig. |
2 |
2 | Head and thorax with dense reddish-brown hair; metasoma without apical bands of whitish hair; metasoma and legs completely reddish (Fig. |
Dioxys ardens (Spain and Portugal) |
– | Head and thorax hairy or only sparsely haired, colour of hairs whitish or brownish; metasoma and legs usually completely or partly black; metasomal terga usually with narrow but well-developed apical bands of whitish hair (Fig. |
3 |
3 | Forecoxa with a toothlike carina anteriorly (Fig. |
4 |
– | Forecoxa rounded anteriorly (Fig. |
5 |
4 | Postscutellum with a medial toothlike projection, which is narrow and elongated (Fig. |
Aglaoapis tridentata |
– | Postscutellum with a medial toothlike process, which is not elongated (Fig. |
Metadioxys graeca (Greece) |
5 | S6 and T6 sharp and elongated (Fig. |
Paradioxys pannonicus |
– | S6 and T6 not elongated (Fig. |
6 |
6 | Apex of T6 truncate; S6 very slightly emarginate apically (Fig. |
Dioxys cinctus |
– | Apex of T6 convex (Fig. |
7 |
7 | Metasoma completely black (Fig. |
Dioxys atlanticus |
– | Metasoma partly reddish (Fig. |
8 |
8 | Legs at least partly reddish (Fig. |
Dioxys pumilus |
– | Legs black (Fig. |
Dioxys moestus |
1 | Scutellum without lateral projections; postscutellum without apical tooth-like process in the middle (Fig. |
Ensliniana bidentata (Spain and Portugal) |
– | Scutellum with lateral toothlike projections, often with medial tooth-like process (Fig. |
2 |
2 | Head and thorax with dense reddish-brown hair; metasoma without apical bands of whitish hair, metasoma and legs completely reddish (Fig. |
Dioxys ardens (Spain and Portugal) |
– | Head and thorax hirsute or only sparsely haired, colour of hairs whitish or brownish; metasoma and legs usually completely or partly black; metasomal terga usually with narrow but well-developed apical bands of whitish hair (Fig. |
3 |
3 | Forecoxa with a toothlike carina anteriorly (Fig. |
4 |
– | Forecoxa rounded anteriorly (Fig. |
5 |
4 | Postscutellum with a medial toothlike projection, which is narrow and elongate (Fig. |
Aglaoapis tridentata |
– | Postscutellum with a medial toothlike process, which is not elongated (Fig. |
Metadioxys graeca (Greece) |
5 | Metasoma completely reddish with semi-transparent apical parts of terga, without well-visible apical bands (Fig. |
Paradioxys pannonicus |
– | Metasoma black or partly reddish (Fig. |
6 |
6 | Apex of S4 medially swollen, bidentate (Fig. |
Dioxys moestus |
– | Apex of S4 straight (Fig. |
7 |
7 | Legs and metasoma partly or completely reddish (Fig. |
Dioxys pumilus |
– | Legs dark, metosoma dark or partly reddish; T7 broad (Fig. |
8 |
8 | Larger species (7–10 mm); at least part of T1 reddish (Fig. |
Dioxys cinctus |
– | Smaller species (5–7 mm); completely black (Fig. |
9 |
9 | Mesonotum, scutellum and T1–T3 densely and deeply punctate, punctures larger; mesosternum medially finely rugose (Fig. |
Dioxys atlanticus |
– | Mesonotum, scutellum and T1–T3 more sparsely and finely punctate, punctures smaller and shallow; mesosternum shiny (Fig. |
Dioxys lanzarotensis (Canary Islands: Lanzarote) |
Altogether, 10 species of five genera of tribe Dioxyini are known to occur in Europe. These are representatives of the genera Aglaoapis Cameron, Ensliniana Alfken, Metadioxys Popov and Paradioxys Mocsáry (one species of each genus) and six species of the genus Dioxys Lepeletier & Serville.
In the neighbouring regions, representatives of the genera Allodioxys Popov, Eudioxys Mavromoustakis and Prodioxys Friese are recorded, but no species of these genera has ever been recorded from Europe. Representatives of these genera differ from European species by the following characteristics (adopted from
Both sexes of Allodioxys have the mesonotum with elongated projections on both sides and postscutellum with a spine-like process medially. Four species occur in the Middle East and/or North Africa (Libya, Algeria, Israel, Syria): Allodioxys ammobius (Mavromoustakis), A. limbifera Pérez, A. moricei (Friese) and A. schulthessi Popov (
Two species of Eudioxys occur in neighbouring regions: Eudioxys quadridentata (Friese) in North Africa (Egypt) and E. schwarzi Mavromoustakis in the Middle East (Iran) (
Three species of Prodioxys occur in North Africa: Prodioxys carneus Gribodo, P. longiventris Pérez and P. rufiventris Lepeletier (
Aglaoapis Cameron, 1901: 262. Type species: Aglaoapis brevipennis Cameron, 1901, monobasic.
Dioxoides Popov, 1947: 89. Type species: Coelioxys tridentata Nylander, 1848, by original designation.
The genus Aglaoapis is distributed in Europe, the Middle East, India and South Africa. Three species are known worldwide (
Coelioxys tridentata Nylander, 1848 (nec Apis tridentata Fabricius, 1775): 254.
Dioxys fasciata Schenck, 1861: 383.
Dioxys kuntzei Noskiewicz, 1940: 99.
Dioxoides tridentata ssp. limassolica Mavromoustakis, 1949: 587.
Larger species (9–12 mm), both sexes are black with well-developed white bands of short hair on metasomal terga (Fig.
Aglaoapis tridentata is a Palaearctic species that occurs in Europe, from Spain in the west to Russia in the east (Fig.
Biology and hosts: Species recorded especially in steppic formations, sunny slopes, forest steppes and other open or semiopen habitats. Occurs also in abandoned sandpits, spoil heaps and other habitats of anthropogenic origin. This species attacks nests of bees of the family Megachilidae, especially those nesting underground or making their own nests near the ground surface. Hoplitis anthocopoides (Schenck), Hoplitis ravouxi (Pérez), probably also Hoplitis adunca (Panzer) and Megachile pilidens Alfken, in southern parts of Europe, and also Chalicodoma parietina (Geoffroy) were confirmed as hosts of this species (
Dioxys Lepeletier & Serville, 1825: 109, type species: Trachusa cincta Jurine, 1807, monobasic.
Hoplopasites Ashmead, 1898: 284, type species: Phileremus productus Cresson, 1879, by original designation.
Chrysopheon Titus, 1901: 256, type species: Chrysopheon aurifuscus Titus, 1901, monobasic.
Dioxys is a Holarctic genus distributed in most of Europe and North Africa to central Asia in the east and the southwestern USA and adjacent Mexico in the western hemisphere (
Dioxys ardens Gerstaecker, 1869: 161.
Dioxys rufispina Pérez, 1895:26.
Larger species, body length 8–10 mm. In both sexes, typical in its colouration, the metasoma is completely reddish without terminal or basal bands, and the legs and flagellum are reddish (Fig.
Species recorded from semideserts and other arid open habitats. Hosts unknown.
This species is known only from several records from southern parts of Spain and one record from Portugal.
In general, a similar species, Dioxys chalicoda Lucas, was recorded from North Africa (Algeria and Libya). One very old record is from Gibraltar, but this specimen was erroneously identified and belongs to D. ardens (coll. Biologiezentrum Linz, Austria). This species differs in the colouration of the metasoma, which has black colouration of at least the last three segments. Females have mandibles with lateral tubercles, and males have ends of S4 with an emargination and S5 and S6 convex.
Dioxys atlanticus Saunders, 1904: 232.
This species is small (5–7 mm in total length) and completely black with well-developed apical bands on metasomal terga (Fig.
This species was described from a male and a female from the Canary Islands (Tenerife), where it was also recorded on two other islands – Lanzarote and Gran Canaria (
The species occurs in open habitats – steppes, semideserts, in rocky areas with shrubby vegetation. Little is known about its biology. Hosts unknown.
Conservation status:
Trachusa cincta Jurine, 1807: 253.
Dioxys pyrenaica Lepeletier, 1841: 515.
Dioxys maura Lepeletier, 1841: 516.
Dioxys cruenta Gerstaecker, 1869: 166.
Dioxys spinigera Pérez, 1884: 299.
Dioxys cincta var. jucunda Mocsáry, 1894: 36.
Dioxys cincta ab. friederikae Mader, 1933: 125.
Dioxys montana
Type specimens of this species and the description were studied in Biologiezentrum Linz, Austria. Both type specimens (a male and a female from the Sertavul Pass in Turkey) do not morphologically differ from typical specimens of D. cinctus.
Larger species, body length variable between 5–12 mm, probably depending on the host. In both sexes, the body is black with the first two metasomal terga entirely or partly reddish and narrow apical bands of whitish short appressed hair (Fig.
A species with a western Palaearctic distribution known from central and southern Europe from Portugal to Greece and Romania (Fig.
Species occurring in a variety of open and semi-open habitats: steppe, semideserts, forest steppes and many others. It was also recorded in sites of anthropogenic origin – former sandpits, quarries, spoil heaps and military exercising areas. This species has more host species in its large distribution area: Chalicodoma parietina, Chalicodoma pyrenaica Lepeletier, Hoplitis adunca and Hoplitis anthocopoides were confirmed (
Dioxys lanzarotensis Tkalcu, 2001: 49–50.
Small species very similar in morphology to D. atlanticus (Fig.
Unknown.
Dioxys moesta Costa, 1883: 96.
Dioxys rotundata Pérez, 1883: 300.
Middle-sized species, body length 5–8 mm. Species with typical general appearance for this genus, black with first 2–3 metasomal terga entirely or partly reddish, with narrow apical bands of whitish short appressed hair (Fig.
Dioxys moestus A female, dorsal view B male, dorsal view C female, mesosoma dorsal view D female, metasoma, dorsal view E female, metasoma lateral F male, last metasomal segments, ventral view G male, T4–T6, dorsal view. Red scale bars represent the length of 1 mm, blue scale bars 100 µm.
This species occurs in open habitats. It was collected in open habitats with shrubby vegetation, steppic formations or rocky landscapes with almond orchards. Hosts are Hoplitis benoisti (Alfken), Hoplitis fertoni (Pérez) and Hoplitis zandeni (Teunissen & van Achterberg) (
Dioxys heinrichi Warncke occurs in North Africa (Morocco and Algeria) and is similar to D. moestus. Female D. heinrichi have a longer F2 and more convex clypeus, and males do not have a swollen end of S4 and lack the two small teeth. The end of S5 is slightly emarginated.
Dioxys pumilus Gerstaecker, 1869: 167.
Dioxys varipes De Stefani, 1887: 113.
Dioxys maroccana Popov, 1936: 16.
Dioxys cypriaca Popov, 1944: 121.
Smaller species, total body length 4–6 mm. Species with typical general appearance for this genus, black with first 2–4 metasomal terga entirely or partly reddish, with narrow apical bands of whitish short appressed hair (Fig.
This is a western Palaearctic species. The nominate subspecies occurs in the eastern Mediterranean basin (Greece, Cyprus, Turkey) (Fig.
This species was recorded in a variety of open and semi-open habitats – steppes, forest steppes, semideserts, open landscapes with shrubby vegetation and many others. Heriades crenulatus Nylander was reported as a likely host of this species in Cyprus (
Ensliniana Alfken, 1938: 431, type species: Ensliniana cuspidata Alfken, 1938 = Stelis bidentata Friese, 1899, by original designation.
Dioxoides Popov, 1947: 89. Type species: Coelioxys tridentata Nylander, 1848, by original designation.
This genus is distributed in North Africa and the Middle East, from Morocco in the west to Turkmenistan in the east. Three species were described, one of which was reported from Europe – Portugal and Spain (
Stelis bidentata Friese, 1899: 285.
Paradioxys pannonica var. rufipes Friese, 1899: 285.
Dioxys richaensis Friese, 1911: 139.
Dioxys bidentata Friese in Schulthess, 1924: 319.
Ensliniana cuspidata Alfken, 1938: 431.
Larger species, body length 7–10 mm. The only species of the genus recorded from Europe. It is typical by the characteristics of the genus; both sexes are generally similar to Dioxys species (Fig.
In Europe, only several specimens are known from Spain and Portugal (Ornosa and Ortiz-Sánchéz 2014;
This species probably occurs in open habitats – steppic grasslands, rocky slopes, semideserts and other habitats.
Metadioxys Popov, 1947: 88, type species: Dioxys formosa Morawitz, 1875, by original designation.
This genus has a similar distribution to the previous genera in North Africa and the Middle East, from Morocco in the west to Uzbekistan in the east. Three species were described, one of which was reported from Europe – Greece (
Dioxys formosa graeca Mavromoustakis, 1963: 696.
Larger species, body length 8–10 mm. Species generally very similar to those of the genus Dioxys, black with first 2–4 metasomal terga entirely or partly reddish (rarely whole metasoma reddish and other body parts reddish), with narrow apical bands of whitish short appressed hair (Fig.
In the European region, this species is known from Greece (Thessaly and Crete) (Fig.
This species probably occurs in open habitats – steppic grasslands, rocky slopes, semideserts and other habitats. Hosts unknown.
Metadioxys formosa Morawitz occurs in North Africa (Morocco) and the Middle East (Israel and Turkmenistan). It is smaller than M. graeca (6–8 mm), and both sexes have scale-like whitish short appressed hair distributed on more parts of the body than M. graeca. Female has last tergum broadened laterally; male has deeply emarginated last sternite.
Paradioxys Mocsáry, 1894: 35, type species: Dioxys pannonica Mocsáry, 1877, monobasic.
This genus is reported from southeastern Europe and the Middle East. Its occurrence ranges from Austria in the west to Iran in the east. Two species are known, one of which occurs in Europe (
Paradioxys pannonica Mocsáry, 1894: 35.
Middle-sized species, body length 7–10 mm. The only species of the genus within Europe. Typical by the characteristics of the genus, similar to species of the genus Dioxys. It is uniform in appearance, females black with first four metasomal terga entirely reddish amd males’ whole metasoma reddish. Legs are also reddish (Fig.
Paradioxys pannonicus A female, dorsal view B male, dorsal view C female, last metasomal segments, dorsal view D male, metasoma, ventral view E male, last metasomal segments, ventral view F male, last metasomal segments, dorsal view. Red scale bars represent the length of 1 mm, blue scale bars 100 µm.
This species was described from Hungary and is a Euro-Asiatic species that occurs from central Europe to the north-eastern Mediterranean (Fig.
This species attacks nests of species of the family Megachilidae.
Cuckoo bees of the tribe Dioxyini are represented by ten species in Europe. These cuckoo bees are usually rare, and sightings are not common. Only two species occur in a large part of the continent. Aglaoapis tridentata is a relatively rare species of steppic habitats whose distribution covers large parts of Europe, including Scandinavia (Sweden and Finland) and Russia. Dioxys cinctus occurs in most of southern and central Europe, where it spreads towards the north – the first record from the northwestern part of the Czech Republic (Bohemia) comes from 2012 (
Several other species were recorded in North Africa or the Middle East. All these species are rare, and their occurrence in Europe is unlikely. The record of Dioxys chalicoda from Gibraltar belongs to D. ardens (P. Bogusch revised). Thus, in future, studies on the distribution of D. atlanticus in southern Europe (if the species will be discovered elsewhere than in Sardinia and Egypt) and attempts to find specimens or populations of P. pannonica would be interesting. Although this species has not recorded for a long time, it is likely to occur in Slovakia, Hungary, Bulgaria, Greece or Romania.
Dioxyini are cuckoo bees. This means that discovering these bees is more complicated than discovering nesting bee species. Their hosts are bees of the family Megachilidae, which usually do not nest in aggregations, and thus their nests are harder to find. However, several species have quite visible nests made of mud (genus Chalicodoma) or can be recorded in bee hotels (hosts of D. cinctus as well as this cuckoo bee species). Furthermore, nests of Hoplitis fertoni parasitised by D. moestus were reported from empty snail shells in Spain (
To preserve the fauna of this tribe of cuckoo bees, it is necessary to take care of their habitats. Most species were recorded mainly in open habitats of steppic or semidesert characteristic. Conservation of these habitats across Europe can go hand in hand with the conservation of the hosts and be helpful for these rare, beautiful and interesting cuckoo bees.
I would like to thank to all curators and collection owners for helping with the material. The study was supported by the Excellence Research Project of University of Hradec Kralove Nr. 2202/2023.