Research Article |
|
Corresponding author: Álvaro Pérez-Gómez ( alvaro.perez@ebd.csic.es ) Academic editor: Petr Janšta
© 2025 Álvaro Pérez-Gómez, Íñigo Sánchez-García, José Manuel Royo, Jean-Yves Rasplus, Jairo Robla.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Pérez-Gómez Álvaro, Sánchez-García Í, Royo JM, Rasplus J-Y, Robla J (2025) Unveiling an intricate relationship: Ficus trees, their associated wasps (Hymenoptera, Chalcidoidea) and another story of invasion in the Iberian Peninsula and Europe. Journal of Hymenoptera Research 98: 667-687. https://doi.org/10.3897/jhr.98.156087
|
The plant genus Ficus (Moraceae) includes keystone tree species in tropical ecosystems, providing essential resources for a wide range of animals. Due to their ornamental value, fig trees have been introduced beyond their native ranges, often accompanied by their natural pollinators, which in some cases has led to ecological invasions. This study documents, for the first time, the presence of several pollinating and non-pollinating fig wasps (Chalcidoidea) on the Iberian Peninsula, focusing on three exotic Ficus species: Ficus microcarpa L.f., 1782, F. rubiginosa Desf. ex Vent., 1805 and F. macrophylla Pers., 1807. Through syconia sampling and dissection, we identified six fig wasp species: the pollinators Eupristina aff. verticillata (Waterston, 1921) and Pleistodontes imperialis Saunders, 1882, the gall-formers Eufroggattisca okinavensis Ishii, 1934, Josephiella microcarpae Beardsley & Rasplus, 2001, Walkerella microcarpae Bouček, 1993, and the parasitoid Philotrypesis okinavensis Ishii, 1934. Additionally, we documented several cases of non-native Ficus species reproducing spontaneously in urban areas, suggesting a significant ecological establishment and invasive spread through sexual reproduction. This spread poses potential risks to urban infrastructure, as the robust root systems of fig trees can damage buildings, pavements, urban trees, and heritage sites. Finally, we observed urban native and non-native bird species consuming mature fig syconia, which likely assist in the dispersal of these plants. Our findings underscore the need for further studies on the ecological impact of introduced Ficus species in non-native regions, their long-term economic consequences for urban heritage, and the continued monitoring of pollinator fig wasp populations.
Alien species, fig wasps, pollinator, parasitoid, Spain
Ficus L. is a well-known genus of woody plants commonly known as fig trees. The genus encompasses ca. 880 species mainly from tropical and subtropical regions (
Agaonids are the main pollinators of Ficus species (
Due to this obligate mutualism, fig trees cannot produce viable seeds without their specific pollinators (
Therefore, it is particularly important to understand not only the actual distribution of fig wasps but also the potential impact of fig trees outside their natural range. In our study, our main goals are to a) record new species of pollinators and non-pollinator Chalcidoidea wasps for the Iberian Peninsula, b) document, for the first time, the spontaneous reproduction of exotic Ficus species in several areas of the Iberian Peninsula. Additionally, we discuss the potential impact of Ficus as invasive species and the damage they could cause to historical monuments in urban areas due to their robust root systems.
Samplings were carried out between 2019 and 2024. Several syconia from the most common ornamental Ficus tree species cultivated in urban parks and gardens in southwestern (Cádiz and Seville) and southeastern (Alicante) Iberian Peninsula (namely, Spain) were collected. Infrutescences were taken to the laboratory and dissected using a 20–60X stereomicroscope. All observed Hymenoptera were sorted and stored in tubes with 70° alcohol. Chalcidoidea wasps were identified following the keys and information provided in:
Once the pollinating wasps of various Ficus species were detected, special attention was given to locating seedlings, recruits, or young Ficus trees whose presence was compatible with sexual rather than asexual reproduction. Thus, the urban areas near the Ficus locations were checked. These studies were not systematic, but rather fortuitous, and the aim was only to detect presence but not to account quantitatively. In cases where Ficus recruits were found, photos were taken, and an attempt was made to assess the damage to the affected area in a subjective and descriptive way.
A total of 2 pollinating (Hymenoptera: Agaonidae) and 4 non-pollinating (Hymenoptera: Epichrysomallidae, Pteromalidae) fig wasps species (Fig.
Wasps cited in this work A female of Eupristina aff. verticillata Waterston, 1921 B Walkerella microcarpae Bouček, 1993 C female and D male of Pleistodontes imperialis Saunders, 1883 E female and F males of Philotrypesis okinavensis Ishii, 1934 G Eufroggattisca okinavensis (Ishii, 1934) H Josephiella microcarpae Beardsley & Rasplus, 2001.
Superfamily Chalcidoidea Latreille, 1817
Family Agaonidae Walker, 1848
Genus Eupristina Saunders, 1883
Spain: • Cádiz: Jerez de la Frontera (Zoobotánico de Jerez): 2♂ + 2♀ ex., Í. Sánchez leg. and MNCN_Ent 235062 deposit., 7-XII-2018, 82 m a.s.l, found in dissected syconia of Ficus microcarpa (36.689315, -6.150638). • Alicante: San Vicente del Raspeig (Universidad de Alicante): 10 ♀ + 7 ♂ ex., J.M. Royo leg. and AC deposit. 5-VII-2023, 92 m a.s.l, found dissecting fallen syconia of Ficus microcarpa. This day, several specimens were seen flying close to the tree (38.384264, -0.512455). See in Fig.
Pollinator of Ficus microcarpa. Also mentioned to be associated with Ficus benjamina L. but without additional data (
This pollinator was described from Malaysia (
Female with head subquadrate, shorter than wide across compound eyes which are as long as the gena; with antennal scrobes separated. Antennae filiform; flagellar segments (except for the proximal two) with a whorl of long black sensilla chaetica (
Spain: • Cádiz: Jerez de la Frontera (Zoobotánico de Jerez): 2♂ + 2♀ ex., Í. Sánchez leg. and AC deposit., 7-XII-2018, 82 m a.s.l., found in dissected syconia of Ficus rubiginosa (36.689315, -6.150638). • Alicante: San Vicente del Raspeig: Vicente Savall Pascual street and University area: 7 ♀ + 8 ♂ ex., J.M. Royo leg. and AC deposit., 5-VII-2023, 193 m a.s.l., found in dissecting fallen syconia of Ficus rubiginosa tree, excepted two females found in syconia of Ficus macrophylla in an urban area (38.389033, -0.518130). See in Fig.
Pollinator of Ficus rubiginosa. One specimen of Pleistodontes cf. imperialis was found inside a syconia of Ficus macrophylla f. columnaris (C. Moore) D. J. Dixon (
Native from eastern Australia (
Small species 1.8–1.9 mm. Female of Pleistodontes can easily be recognized by their elongated head, with long subparallel genae, mandibular appendage elongate, usually bearing more than 20 transverse laminae, rarely less, sometimes bearing transverse rows of small teeth (
Genus Eufroggattisca Ghesquière 1946
Spain: • Cádiz: Jerez de la Frontera (Zoobotánico de Jerez): 2♂ + 3♀ ex., Í. Sánchez leg. and MNCN_Ent 235061 deposit., 7-XII-2018, 82 m a.s.l, found dissecting syconia of Ficus microcarpa (36.689315, -6.150638). • Alicante: San Vicente del Raspeig (Universidad de Alicante): 10 ♀ + 10 ♂ ex., J.M. Royo leg. and AC deposit. 19-V-2024, 92 m a.s.l, found dissecting syconia of Ficus microcarpa (38.384264, -0.512455). See Fig.
Large galler in syconium of Ficus microcarpa. In Greece, Eufroggattisca okinavensis was repeatedly recorded from the same syconia as Meselatus bicolor, whose large galls suggest a possible host-parasitoid or inquiline relationship (
Originally from eastern Asia (China, Japan and Taiwan) and Australia (
The species exhibits the following combination of characters: Head with occipital carina. In male petiole distinct, only slightly transverse, and pronotum long, much narrower than mesoscutum. Scutellum with two pairs of bristles (
Spain: • Alicante: San Vicente del Raspeig: Vicente Savall Pascual Street: 4 ♀ ex., J.M. Royo leg. and AC deposit., 02-II-2021, 193 m a.s.l, found in dissecting leaf galls of Ficus microcarpa (38.389033, -0.518130). • Cádiz: Algeciras: Barriada El Cobre: 8 ♀+ 1 ♂ ex., I. Sánchez and Á. Pérez leg and AC deposit. 15-VIII-2019, 84 m a.s.l, found in dissecting leaf galls of F. microcarpa (36.118236, -5.479646). See Fig.
Leaf galler of Ficus microcarpa.
The exact origin of the wasp is unknown but could be Southeast Asia as its host plant originates from there. The species was first reported in Hawaii, California (USA) and the Canary Islands (Spain) (
The female has a body uniformly dark brown except antennal and legs pale yellow, wings hyaline. Head reticulate in dorsal occipital area behind ocelli. Pronotum reticulate without carinae, mesoscutum smooth centrally, scutellum smooth with weak, longitudinally oriented reticulation. Hind coxae reticulate. Gaster smooth and shiny (
Subfamily Pteromalinae Dalman, 1820
Tribe Otitesellini (see
Genus Walkerella Westwood 1883
Spain: • Cádiz: Jerez de la Frontera (Zoobotánico de Jerez): 3♂ + 3♀ ex., Í. Sánchez leg. and MNCN_Ent 235063 deposit., 7-XII-2018, 82 m a.s.l., found in dissected syconia of Ficus microcarpa (36.689315, -6.150638). • Alicante: San Vicente del Raspeig (Universidad de Alicante): 11 ♀ + 5 ♂ ex., J.M. Royo leg. and AC deposit., 5-VII-2023, 92 m a.s.l., found dissecting fallen syconia of Ficus microcarpa and some flying specimens close to the tree (38.384264, -0.512455). See in Fig.
Gall-forming wasp in figs of Ficus microcarpa.
This species probably originates from the Oriental region and was introduced to the Palearctic and the Nearctic (
Difficult to separate morphologically from other genera of European Pteromalidae. Walkerella is recognized by the following characters: body blackish, without conspicuous external ovipositor and apterous males with long mandibles. The genus Otitesella is also present in the Palearctic region (associated with Platyscapa). Also, the genus Micranisa from Greece and Cyprus (
Spain: • Cádiz: Puerto Real: 2 ♂ + 1 ♀ ex., A. Pérez-Gómez leg. and AC. deposit., 10-XI-2020, 316 m a.s.l., found dissecting fallen syconia of Ficus microcarpa (36.530600, -6.211997). See in Fig.
Parasitoid of Eupristina verticillata and W. microcarpae (see
This species originates from eastern Asia, namely China, Hong Kong, Japan and Taiwan (
Female yellowish red brown in general. Antennae brown except the scape which is yellowish red brown; abdominal segments 5–6 with transverse brown band at the base; segments 7–9 with a median longitudinal brown band; ovipositor black. Mandible tridentate the lower tooth largest. Mesoscutum and scutellum with a shallow median longitudinal furrow; propodeum with three longitudinal keels, the median one only indicated in the anterior half; Wings hyaline, the veins pale brown. Legs yellowish red-brown. Abdomen almost as long as the head and thorax combined, long ovate; stalk very short; ovipositor if the abdomen, dilated in the middle.
Regeneration cases of various Ficus species have been documented across the three study areas in this research. Seedlings and saplings of different sizes are abundant near adult fig trees planted for ornamental purposes in urban areas (e.g., close Guadalquivir river in Seville; 37.404262, -5.998787; or the city centre of Seville, 37.377322, -5.991610; or in Jerez de la Frontera, 36.688914, -6.150606). These young plants have been found in diverse environments, contributing to different types of damage. Common sites for these regrowths include small cracks or gaps in pavements (Fig.
Ficus species impacting urban monuments and structures A Ficus microcarpa in the moat of the Rectorate in Seville and B on a watchtower of the Cádiz city wall C Ficus macrophylla emerging from a drainage outlet on the roof of the Tempul water reservoir (Jerez de la Frontera) D on a wall in Jerez de la Frontera, and E, F on ornamental palm trees in Alicante.
Particularly interesting are the occasional observations we have made while searching for Ficus seedlings and saplings, in which certain urban bird species were seen feeding on the mature syconia of these trees. These species include the common wood pigeon Columba palumbus L., the house sparrow Passer domesticus L., and, the invasive rose-ringed parakeet Psittacula krameri Scopoli, both in the María Luisa’s urban park in Seville (37.378662, -5.988352) or in the ZooBotánico Jerez (36.689533, -6.150595).
Biological invasions are of global concern with significant ecological, health, and socioeconomic impacts (
Our detection of sexual reproduction in Ficus species in Spain (and in mainland Europe), and outside their native ranges signals a new biological invasion case with potentially severe future impacts. Curiously, there are very few cases reporting the spontaneous sprouting of fig trees in Europe, most of them from island areas (e.g.,
With this new case of a biological invasion in the Iberian Peninsula, many questions remain. First, we need to refine our understanding of the distribution of these fig wasps and identify areas where they may promote the natural reproduction and spread of Ficus trees. Second, it is essential to assess the damage that Ficus can cause in urban and natural settings. Finally, it is important to investigate potential synergies with other species that may act as dispersers and amplify the invasive impact of these trees.