Research Article |
Corresponding author: Maxim Yu. Proshchalykin ( proshchalikin@biosoil.ru ) Academic editor: Jack Neff
© 2022 Yulia V. Astafurova, Maxim Yu. Proshchalykin.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Astafurova YV, Proshchalykin MY (2022) Review of the Epeolus cruciger species group (Hymenoptera, Apidae, Epeolus Latreille, 1802) of Asia, with the description of two new species. Journal of Hymenoptera Research 92: 305-328. https://doi.org/10.3897/jhr.92.90098
|
The six species of the Epeolus cruciger species group from Asia are reviewed. Two new species, Epeolus asiaticus Astafurova & Proshchalykin, sp. nov. (Mongolia, Russia) and E. gorodkovi Astafurova, sp. nov. (Tajikistan, Afghanistan) are described and illustrated. Epeolus alpinus Friese, 1893 is newly recorded from Kazakhstan; E. cruciger (Panzer, 1799) is newly recorded from Turkmenistan, Uzbekistan, and Kyrgyzstan; and E. mongolicus Astafurova & Proshchalykin, 2021 is newly recorded from Kyrgyzstan and Russia. An identification key for both sexes of all Asian members of this species group is presented.
Anthophila, Apiformes, cleptoparasites, Palaearctic region, taxonomy
The present paper is part of a series of works dealing with the bees of the genus Epeolus Latreille, 1802 of the Asian Palaearctic (
There, the cruciger species group includes Epeolus alpinus Friese, 1893, E. cruciger (Panzer, 1799), E. laevifrons Bischoff, 1930, E. schummeli Schilling, 1849, E. sigillatus Alfken, 1930, and E. mongolicus Astafurova & Proshchalykin, 2021 (
Here, we add two new species to this group: E. asiaticus Astafurova & Proshchalykin, sp. nov. and E. gorodkovi Astafurova, sp. nov. from various territories of Central Asia.
The results presented in this paper are based on 640 Epeolus cruciger species group specimens currently housed in the Zoological Institute, Russian Academy of Sciences (St. Petersburg, Russia,
The taxonomy and synonymy of species follow those of
Abbreviations T and S are used for metasomal tergum and metasomal sternum, respectively.
The species are listed alphabetically. We have used the following abbreviations for collectors: AL – A. Lelej; DS – D. Sidorov, JH – J. Halada, MK – M. Kozlov, MP – M. Proshchalykin; PK – P. Kozlov, SB – S. Belokobylskij; SL – S. Luzyanin; VL – V. Loktionov.
Specimens were studied with an Olympus SZ51 stereomicroscope and photographs were taken with a combination of stereomicroscope (Olympus SZX10) and digital camera (Olympus OM-D). Final images are stacked composites generated using Helicon Focus 7.7.4 Pro. All images were post-processed for contrast and brightness using Adobe Photoshop. New distributional records are noted with an asterisk (*).
Epeolus Latreille, 1802: 427. Type species: Apis variegata Linnaeus, 1758, monobasic.
Labrum with apical margin straight or medially slightly curved, with small distinct medial tooth; sub-apically (as opposed to medially, as in species in the Epeolus variegatus species group, or apically, as in species in the E. julliani species group) with two obvious teeth (tubercles). Axilla flat, with small apical tooth or without distinct tooth. Species of the group are quite variable in the body size, coloration and pubescence.
Epeolus alpinus Friese, 1893, E. asiaticus Astafurova & Proshchalykin, sp. nov., E. cruciger (Panzer, 1799), E. gorodkovi Astafurova sp. nov., E. laevifrons Bischoff, 1930, E. mongolicus Astafurova & Proshchalykin, 2021, E. schummeli Schilling, 1849, E. sigillatus Alfken, 1930.
1 | Vertex not elevated, hardly visible as seen as frontal view | 2 |
– | Vertex elevated, obvious, distance from top of head to upper margin of lateral ocellus about two lateral ocellar diameters as seen in frontal view | E. schummeli Schilling |
2 | Upper half of frons with short simple setae and confluent punctures. Terga with apical bands of tomentum interrupted. Male gonostylus mostly parallel-sided as seen in lateral view (Fig. |
E. cruciger (Panzer) |
– | Upper half of frons with relatively long, erect simple setae (can be mixed with adpressed, plumose pubescence) and usually with polished interspaces between punctures (confluent punctures without distinct polished interspaces as in E. gorodkovi sp. nov.). Terga with apical bands of tomentum uninterrupted or interrupted. Male gonostylus apically distinctly curved and triangular as seen as lateral view (Fig. |
3 |
3 | Pubescence coloration monochromatic (golden or copper); terga entirely covered with dense tomentum | E. mongolicus Astafurova & Proshchalykin (male unknown) |
– | Pubescence coloration mixed (whitish/yellowish and brownish) or yellowish monochromatic; tergal pubescence heterogeneous, dense tomentum foming light, well-visible spots or bands | 4 |
4 | Tergal discs entirely black. Labrum, pronotal lobes, axillae and mesoscutellum black, reddish or amber | 5 |
– | Tergal coloration variable, but yellow-reddish pattern usually well-developed or at least on posterior half of T5 (Fig. |
E. asiaticus sp. nov. |
5 | Terga each with uninterrupted apical band of tomentum; marginal zones pale-yellow to golden | E. gorodkovi sp. nov. |
– | Terga each with interrupted apical band of tomentum; marginal zones black or brownish | 6 |
6 | Mesoscutum and mesoscutellum sparsely punctate with punctures separated by more than one puncture diameter | E. laevifrons Bischoff |
– | Mesoscutum and mesoscutellum densely punctate with confluent punctures to separated by about one puncture diameter | E. alpinus Friese |
Epeolus alpinus Friese, 1893: 34, ♀, ♂ (type locality: Goeschenen, Switzerland), Natural History Museum, Berlin.
Epeolus variegatus Thomson, 1872 (nom. praeocc., nec Linnaeus, 1758): 212, ♀ (type locality: unknown), Zoological Museum, University of Lund, Sweden.
Epeolus glacialis Alfken, 1913: 36, nomen novum for E. variegatus Thomson, 1872.
Epeolus montanus Bischoff, 1930: 9, ♀, ♂ (type locality: Warnemünde, Germany), Natural History Museum, Berlin.
Epeolus pilosus Bischoff, 1930: 9–10, ♀, ♂ (type locality: Rositten [=Rybachij], Kaliningrad Prov., Russia), Natural History Museum, Berlin.
Epeolus alpinus Bischoff, 1930 (nom. praeocc., nec Friese, 1893): 9–10, ♀ (type locality: Saas, Switzerland), Natural History Museum, Berlin.
Russia, Sverdlovsk Prov., Sysertskiy distr., Dvurechensk, 18.VII.2009, (1 ♀), K. Fadeev [
Asian specimens examined are on average bigger than European ones (6.0–8.0 mm vs 5.0–6.0 mm). Female. Unlike E. cruciger and E. asiaticus sp. nov., this species does not have individuals with a red pattern on integunent of the metasomal terga. The pronotal lobe, mesoscutellum and axillae are red in most of studied Asian specimens; these structures are mostly black in specimens from the European range; only 6% of all examined females have a red labrum. Pubescence of the head and mesosoma, tergal bands or spots of tomentum are white or pale yellow. The mesoscutum is without tomentum in most specimens, rarely with weak tomentum anteriorly. Most examined specimens have widely interrupted apical bands of pale tomentum on T1 and T2 and two pairs of spots of pale tomentum on T3 and T4 (Fig.
Europe, Turkey, Iran, Russia, *Kazakhstan (Kokchetau Province), Mongolia (
Holotype
: ♀, Mongolia, Terkhin-Gol, Chulut and Khoit Rivers, 30.VI.1975, E. Narchuk [
Russia, Tuva Rep., 25 km SE Erzin, Tes-Khem River, 14–15.VII.2014, (1 ♀), AL, MP, VL [
Structurally and in sharing long setae on the upper half of frons the new species is closest to Epeolus alpinus, E. laevifrons, E. gorodkovi sp. nov. and E. mongolicus. The new species differs from Epeolus alpinus, E. laevifrons and E. gorodkovi in having yellow-reddish (amber) pattern on metasomal terga (vs entirely black) and from E. mongolicus in having sparser pubescence on tergal discs (vs dense, as well as tomentum on marginal zones in E. mongolicus). Differences between the new species and other species of the cruciger group are outlined in Table
Differences between females and males of Epeolus cruciger, E. mongolicus, E. asiaticus, E. alpinus, and E. gorodkovi.
cruciger | mongolicus | asiaticus | alpinus | gorodkovi | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Female | |||||
Upper half of frons | with short setae and mostly confluent punctures | with relatively long erect simple setae (can be mixed with appressed plumose pubescence usually extending ocelli); with polished interspaces between punctures | with relatively long erect setae; with polished interspaces between punctures | with relatively long erect setae and mostly confluent punctures | |
Labrum on apical margin | curved medially | slightly curved medially or more distinctly curved in large specimens | straight or slightly curved medially | ||
Punctation of mesoscutum | with punctures from mostly confluent to separated by a half puncture diameter, without distinct interspaces | with punctures from confluent to separated by at least a puncture diameter, usually with distinct polished interspaces | with punctures from mostly confluent to separated by a half puncture diameter, without distinct interspaces | ||
Pubescence of mesoscutum | without tomentum or with a pair short paramedial strips | entirely covered with tomentum (but tomentum can be strongly shabby) | usually well developed on an anterior half, but without distinct paramedial strips | slightly developed, usually without paramedial strips | developed only on anterior margin |
T2 apical band or spots of tomentum | widely interrupted band forming a pair of lateral spots, sometimes reduced to two pair small lateral spots | uninterrupted band, visually merged with dense discal pubescence | uninterrupted or narrowly interrupted medially | widely interrupted medially band (narrowly interrupted in Sakhalin specimens) | uninterrupted band |
T3-T4 apical band or spots of tomentum | two pair (or extremely rare only a pair) whitish spots | uninterrupted bands, visually merged with dense discal pubescence | variable, usually uninterrupted or narrowly interrupted medially bands, or rarely with additional lateral interruption forming 2 or 4 spots | with a pair of large spots (sometimes with an additional pair of small lateral spots); in Sakhalin specimens with narrowly interrupted medially band or T4 uninterrupted band | uninterrupted bands |
Coloration of labrum, pronotal lobes, axilla and mesoscutellum | variable from black to red or yellowish (amber) | always yellow-reddish (amber) | always yellow-reddish (amber) | variable from black to red or yellowish (amber) | black |
Coloration of terga | extremely variable from black to reddish | yellow-reddish (amber); marginal zones yellowish | variable, from mostly black with small yellow-reddish (amber) pattern to mostly yellow-reddish; marginal zones light | black; marginal zones always dark (black or brownish) | black; marginal zones yellowish |
Coloration of tergal band/spot of tomentum | white or yellow | copper or gold | yellowish (from pale to golden) | whitish or yellowish | whitish and yellowish |
Pubescence on tergal discs | sparser than tomentum on marginal zones, from black or dark brownish to light brownish and rarely yellowish | dense (as well as tomentum on marginal zones), copper or golden | sparser than tomentum on marginal zones; yellowish, golden, brown (the same coloration or darker than tomentum on marginal zones) | sparser than tomentum on marginal zones; dark brown | sparser than tomentum on marginal zones, dark brown |
Male | |||||
Upper half of frons | with short setae and confluent punctures | unknown | with relatively long erect simple setae (can be mixed with appressed plumose pubescence extending ocelli); with polished interspaces between punctures | with relatively long erect simple setae (maybe shabby!); with polished interspaces between punctures | relatively with long setae and confluent punctures |
Apical band or spots of tomentum | whitish; on T1 and T2 widely interrupted bands; on T3 and T4 two pairs of spots | uninterrupted yellowish band | T1-T3 with interrupted medially whitish band, on T4 narrowly interrupted or uninterrupted band, or on T3 and T4 often reduced to 4 spots | uninterrupted whitish band | |
Coloration of terga | black | variable, with different proportion black and yellow-red, marginal zones transparent and pale-yellow or yellow. | black, marginal zones black or brownish | black, marginal zones pale-yellow to golden | |
Gonostylus apical area [membranous area with long setae and curved towards central axis] | narrow as seen as ventral view | relatively wide as seen as ventral view | |||
Gonostylus in lateral view | almost parallel-sided | apically triangular, distinctly curved |
Female (holotype). Total body length 8.0 mm (Fig.
Structure and sculpture: Head (Fig.
Integument coloration: Head mostly black, but mandibles (excluding dark apex), labrum, clypeus along apical margin, and F1 (partly) yellow-red (amber). Mesosoma mostly black; pronotal lobe, tegulae, axillae, mesoscutellum, metanotum medially and legs (including spurs) yellow-red (amber); wings with brownish darkening, stigma and veins brown. Metasomal terga mostly black, but yellow-red on posterior half of T1, along marginal zones of T2–T4 (narrow strip), and posterior half of T5; marginal zones amber, transparent. Pygidial plate yellow-red with brownish edging. Sterna brownish, yellow-red laterally and along marginal zones; marginal zones pale yellow.
Pubescence: Pale tomentum yellow to white. Labrum with sparse thin golden setae. Paraocular and supraclypeal areas with dense tomentum obscuring integument, clypeus with sparse pubescence. Upper half of frons with long simple setae (Fig.
Male. Structure, sculpture, coloration and pubescence are similar to those of the female (Fig.
Female. Total body length is 4.5–9.0 mm. The mesoscutellum is usually flattened with a weak medial longitudinal impression, but in large specimens this impression can sometimes be deep. The labrum, mandible, pronotal lobe, tegulae, legs, axillae and mesoscutellum are always yellow-reddish (amber); the clypeus is usually yellow-reddish apically as well as scape and partly F1. The females of this new species exhibit considerable intraspecific variation in the metasomal coloration and degree of development of the tergal tomentum bands. This variability is expressed in a huge variety of combinations of these features (Fig.
Apical bands on T1–T4 typically uninterrupted (Fig.
In nine (5%) female specimens, the second submarginal crossvein is incomplete or lacking completely (Fig.
Male. Total body length 5.0–7.0 mm. The apical margin of the pygidial plate is sometimes straight or rarely slightly bilobed. The coloration of pedicel, scape and F1 varies from partly yellow-red to brownish. Variation in metasomal integument coloration is similar to that of the female with different proportions of black and yellow-red (Fig.
The specific name “asiaticus” is an adjective in the nominative singular that means “Asian” in Latin and refers to the occurrence of this species in Asia.
Russia (Tyva Rep., Zabaikalskiy Terr.), Mongolia (Arkhangai, Bayankhongor, Bayan-Ölgii, Dornod, Dornogovi, Govi-Altai, Khuvsgul, Omnogovi, Selenge, Sukhbaatar, Tuv, Ulaanbaatar, Uvs, Uvurkhangai, Zavkhan).
Nomada crucigera Panzer, 1799: 20, ♂ (type locality: Austria), Natural History Museum, Berlin.
Epeolus rufipes Thomson, 1870: 91, ♀ (type locality: S-Sweden), Zoological Museum of University Lund, Sweden.
Epeolus similis Höppner, 1899: 355–356, ♀, ♂ (type locality: Freisenbüttel, Germany), Natural History Museum, Berlin.
Epeolus cruciger var. elegans Müller, 1921: 168, ♀ (type locality: Arnswalde, Germany), Natural History Museum, Berlin.
Epeolus cruciger var. rufiventris Müller, 1921: 168, ♀ (type locality: Arnswalde, Germany), Natural History Museum, Berlin.
Epeolus marginatus Bischoff, 1930: 11, ♀, ♂ (type locality: Warnemünde, Germany), Natural History Museum, Berlin.
Russia, Chelyabinsk Prov., Metlino, 23.VIII.2004, (3 ♀), P. Rudoiskatel [
We also have examined 80 specimens of this species (36 ♀, 44 ♂) from the European part of Russia and from the Caucasus. We have not listed materials from Yakutia published by
Europe, Turkey, Syria, Iran, Russia, Kazakhstan, *Turkmenistan, *Uzbekistan, *Kyrgyzstan, Mongolia (Dornod, Khentii, Khovd, Khuvsgul) (
Female. Integument coloration. There are two main forms: dark with black/brownish metasoma (Fig.
Holotype
: ♂, Tajikistan, Pamir Mts, Murgab River Valley, Zapadny Pshart River, 3325 m, on Myricana squamosa, 29.VI.1958, K. Gorogkov [
Structurally and in coloration, the new species is very similar to Epeolus alpinus but differs in having uninterrupted apical tergal bands, denser and lighter pubescence on tergal discs (light brown to yellowish) and yellowish marginal zones on terga (black or brownish in alpinus). The upper half of frons, ocellocular area and mesoscutum are mostly confluently punctate (with a few shiny interspaces) and similar to those in E. cruciger. Differences between the new species and other species of the cruciger group are outlined in Table
Male (holotype). Total body length 6.5 mm (Fig.
Structure and sculpture: Head (Fig.
Integument coloration. Head black, except partly red-yellowish mandibles, brownish antennae and apically yellowish F1. Mesosoma black, except red-yellowish tegulae, tibiae and tarsi. Metasomal terga black, but marginal zones pale-yellow to golden. Sterna brownish with marginal zones the same color as on terga.
Pubescence: Tomentum whitish to yellow (except sometimes brownish on tergal discs). Labrum apically with sparse thin setae. Paraocular and supraclypeal areas with dense tomentum obscuring integument, pubescence on clypeus sparser, shorter and shabby. Upper half of frons with long simple setae. Vertex with sparse thick (plumose) setae. Gena with dense tomentum, but not obscuring integument. Pronotum dorsally with tomentum obscuring integument. Mesoscutum with tomentum of adpressed plumose setae (dense on anterior third and peripherally) and long erect simple setae. Metanotal integumentalmost obscured by short tomentum. Mesepisternum and ventral parts of mesosoma with long tomentum obscuring integument. Legs with white setae. Terga (Fig.
Female. Structure, sculpture, coloration and pubescence are similar to those of the male (Fig.
The male specimen from Afghanistan has a red labrum, F1, pronotal lobes and pygidial plate.
The new species is named in honor of famous Russian entomologist and zoogeographer Kirill B. Gorodkov (1932–2001), the collector of the type series.
Tajikistan, Afghanistan.
Epeolus mongolicus
Astafurova & Proshchalykin, 2021b: 19, ♀ (holotype: ♀, W Mongolia, Zavkhan, 40 km SW of Uliastay [
Kyrgyzstan, Ak-Ulen, Issyk-Kul Lake, 29.VI.1953, (1 ♀), D. Panfilov [
*Kyrgyzstan, Mongolia (Bulgan, Zavkhan), *Russia (Tyva Republic) (
Male unknown.
Epeolus schummeli Schilling, 1849: 104, ♀ (type locality: Schlesien), type lost.
Epeolus ruthenicus Radoszkowski, 1891: 245, ♂ (type locality: Minsk, Belarus), Natural History Museum, Berlin.
Belarus, Grodno, (1 ♀), coll. F. Morawitz [E. variegatus Morawitz det.] [
Central and southern Europe, Caucasus, Turkey, Middle East, Ukraine, Belarus, Russia (south of the European part) (
The Epeolus cruciger species group is distributed only in the Palaearctic region, and its range extends from northern Africa to the Russian Far East and China. Epeolus cruciger is most widespread and occurs from Europe over Central Asia to the Russian Far East. Epeolus alpinus is also widespread from Europe to the Far East, but it is mostly a boreal species and in the southern part of its range occurs in mountainous areas. Epeolus schummeli is a Western Palaearctic species, but is not known north of Poland. The rest of the species have narrow ranges or are endemic: Epeolus laevifrons (North Africa, Turkey), E. sigillatus (Greece: Crete), E. mongolicus and E. asiaticus (Mongolia and adjacent territory) and E. gorodkovi (mountains of Tajikistan and Afghanistan). No specimens of the group are recorded in Japan.
The females of several species demonstrate considerable intraspecific variation, but the males are less variable. Two species—E. cruciger and E. asiaticus—exhibit extreme variation in metasomal integumental coloration, having dark and light forms. In E. cruciger, the black forms predominate in the forest zone and are rarer in the steppe zone. However, both forms can be found in the same location. The same rule works for pubescence coloration, as brighter pubescence is generally exhibited by individuals from the southern area of its range. The large variation in body size is characteristic of most of species of this group (difference up to 1.5–2 times between the smallest and largest specimens). It should be noted that E. alpinus specimens from Asia are on average bigger than European ones. The Sakhalin population of E. alpinus represents a great example of differences between isolated island populations and typical continental forms, expressed in the development of the apical tomentum on terga. However, this case needs further investigation to determine whether subspecies or species status is warranted. Remarkable vitiation is seen in the reduction of the second submarginal crossvein (incomplete or lacking completely) found in 5% of female specimens of E. asiaticus. A similar phenomenon was also found in species from North America (
We are grateful to Fritz Gusenleitner (
This investigation was supported by the Russian Funds for Basic Research (grant number 20–54–44014), and the state research projects 122031100272-3 and 121031000151-3.